Over the Limit featured professional wrestling matches that involved different wrestlers from pre-existing feuds, plots, and storylines which were played out on WWE's primary television programs, Raw and SmackDown. Wrestlers portrayed villains or heroes as they followed a series of events that built tension and culminated in a wrestling match or series of matches.
One of the prominent feuds from the Raw brand was between John Cena and the General Manager of Raw and SmackDown, John Laurinaitis. On the night after losing to The Rock in the main event of WrestleMania XXVIII in early April, Cena's promo was interrupted by a returning Brock Lesnar, who immediately attacked him with an F-5. It was revealed the next week on Raw that Laurinaitis hired Lesnar to replace Cena as "the face of the WWE" by taking him out at Extreme Rules. A battered Cena barely managed to defeat Lesnar, and in a post-match promo, emphasized his injuries and announced he would be "taking a vacation." The next night on Raw, Lesnar attacked WWE COO Triple H (while he was arguing with Laurinaitis about the validity of Lesnar's contract), breaking his arm. With Lesnar's WWE job now in jeopardy, and after advice from his Executive Administrator Eve Torres, Laurinaitis decided on Cena's next opponent, for Over the Limit. Later that night, while Cena was in the ring, Laurinaitis appeared on the entrance stage to announce that opponent, and introduced Lord Tensai. Laurinaitis and Tensai then attacked Cena, and Laurinaitis revealed that he (Laurinaitis) would be Cena's opponent. The WWE Board of Directors stipulated the only way to win would be by pinfall or submission, anybody interfering in the match would be immediately fired and, if Laurinaitis lost the match, he would be fired.
The main storyline from the SmackDown brand led to World Heavyweight ChampionSheamus defending his title in a Fatal 4-Way match against Alberto Del Rio, Randy Orton, and Chris Jericho. After defeating Daniel Bryan in 18 seconds at WrestleMania XXVIII to win the title, Sheamus faced a returning Alberto Del Rio in a non-title match on the April 6 edition of SmackDown. Del Rio defeated Sheamus via disqualification to earn a future title shot. Sheamus again defeated Bryan at Extreme Rules to retain his title and end their rivalry, opening the way for Del Rio's title opportunity at Over the Limit. On the May 7 episode of Raw, Sheamus and Orton faced Jericho and Del Rio in a tag team match. Jericho pinned Sheamus after a Codebreaker, after Sheamus accidentally kicked Orton in the face. They argued, in John Laurinaitis' office, about who should be next in line for the title. Laurinaitis announced a Fatal 4-Way match for the World Heavyweight Championship at Over the Limit, instead of the originally advertised singles match between Sheamus and Del Rio.
Pre-Show
The Pre-Show match was Kane vs. Zack Ryder in a one on one match. Kane won the match via pinfall after performing a Chokeslam.
Event
The first match of the night was a 20 man Battle Royal for a United States championship or Intercontinental championship match. It was ultimately won by Christian.
The next match was Kofi Kingston and R Truth defending the WWE Tag Team Championships against Dolph Ziggler and Jack Swagger. The two teams took turns controlling the match. It was Truth and Kingston who got the win and retained the tag titles
Then, Layla defended her Divas championship against Beth Phoenix. Beth tried to nail Layla with a Glamslam but Layla countered it and hit the Lay-Out to retain.
The fourth match of the night was Sheamus defending the World Heavyweight Championship against Chris Jericho, Randy Orton, and Alberto Del Rio in a Fatal 4 way match. They hit each other with their Finshers but kept kicking out. The match came to an end when Sheamus nailed Jericho with The White Noise.
Then, Cody Rhodes defended the Intercontinental title against Christian who won the Battle Royal earlier that night. Christian controlled the match all the way and pinned Rhodes after a Killswitch.
Then CM Punk defended the WWE championship against Daniel Bryan. Both Punk and Bryan took over each other, in the end when Bryan had Punk in the Yes Lock, Punk pinned Bryan to retain the title despite tapping out immediately thereafter.
The next one was Ryback taking on Camacho. Ryback won the match.
The main event was John Cena taking on Raw and SmackDown General Manager John Laurinaitis. John Cena took control of
the match and threw trash on him. Laurninaitis ran away from the ring but was caught by Big Show. Big show threw Laurinaitis
back in the ring when Cena was going to hit a AA on Laurninaitis but Big Show hit Cena with a WMD. Laurinaitis pinned Cena and won the match.
Results
Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
(c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.