The Mechanics faced their match as a team on the February 18, 2015 tapings against The Vaudevillains, with a loss. Afterward's they appeared sporadically on NXT usually against other team's, often on the losing end.
The duo gained their first victory as a team, in an upset victory over Enzo Amore and Colin Cassady, on the July 16 tapings. The Mechanic's teamed up with Jason Jordan & Chad Gable in an eight-man tag match on the pre-show of NXT TakeOver Brooklyn against Enzo Amore, Colin Cassady, Zack Ryder and Mojo Rawley, which they lost.
The Mechanic's competed in the first round of the NXT Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic tournament, which they moved to the quarterfinal's after defeating the team of Elias Samson and Tucker Knight.
On the October 22 tapings, they defeated The Vaudevillains for the NXT Tag Team Championships.