In July 2014, Heath Slater formed a tag team with O'Neil, later known as Slater Gator. In July and August, they largely wrestled on Main Event and Superstars. Despite wins over the likes of Sin Cara & Zack Ryder and Goldust & Stardust, they suffered losses to the likes of Hornswoggle & El Torito and Big E & Kofi Kingston. In September, Slater Gator featured more on Raw, but this was at the expense of O'Neil losing multiple matches to Adam Rose, as well as Slater Gator losing to the team of Rose and the Bunny.
On the February 16th episode of Raw, O'Neil turned face by saving his former tag team partner Darren Young from an attack from The Ascension. Then on the 23 February edition of Raw, The Prime Time Players officially reunited, effectively ending Slater Gator.
- O'Neil's finishing moves
- Clash of the Titus(Lifting sitout spinebuster)
- Slater's finishing moves
- Sweetness(Jumping Russian legsweep)
- Entrance themes
- "More than One man" / "Three Man Band" by Jim Johnston (July 2014–September 29, 2014; Slater's Entrance Music)
- "Let Me Show You" (Slater Gator Remix)" by CFO$ (September 29, 2014 - February 16, 2015)