The Lucha Sisters (February 28, 2014-June 27, 2014)[]
- Defeated Made In Sin in tournament finals to become the inaugural champions (SHINE 17)
- Defeated The S-N-S Express (A Wrestling Odyssey)
- Defeated Evie & Kellie Skater (SHINE 19)
- Defeated Candice LeRae & Ivelisse (FIP Florida Rumble 2014)
Legendary (June 27, 2014-March 6, 2015)[]
- Defeated The Lucha Sisters to become new champions (SHINE 20)
- Defeated The Lucha Sisters (SHINE 21)
- Defeated The Buddy System (SHINE 22)
- Defeated The Kimber Bombs (SHINE 23)
The Kimber Bombs (March 6, 2015-October 2, 2015)[]
- Defeated Legendary to become new champions (SHINE 25)
- The Global Green Gangsters (c) [SHIMMER] vs. The Kimber Bombs (c) [SHINE] ended in Double Count Out (SHINE 26)
- Both SHINE Tag Team Championship and SHIMMER Tag Team Championship were on the line.
- Defeated Legendary (SHINE 27)
- The Kimber Bombs vs. Valifornia ended in No Contest (SHINE 28)
Better Than You (December 11, 2015-December 16, 2016)[]
- Defeated The Lucha Sisters in tournament finals to win the vacant championships (SHINE 31)
- Defeated Las Sicarias Emerges (Ivelisse & Amanda Carolina Rodriguez) (SHINE 33)
- Defeated Evie & Shazza McKenzie (SHINE 36)
- Defeated Dominique Fabiano & Priscilla Kelly (SHINE 37)
Santana Garrett & Raquel (December 16, 2016-May 12, 2017)[]
- Defeated Better Than You to become the new champions (SHINE 39)
- Defeated Las Sicarias (Amanda Carolina Rodriguez & Thea Trinidad) and C4 (Amber O'Neal & Kennadi Brink) (SHINE 40)
- Three Corners Match
- Defeated Kennadi Brink & Vanessa Kraven (SHINE 41)
Las Sicarias (May 12, 2017-July 20, 2018)[]
- Defeated Santana Garrett & Raquel to become the new champions (SHINE 42)
- Defeated Twisted Sisterz (Thunder Rosa & Holidead) (SHINE 46)
- Defeated The Cutie Pie Club (Aria Blake & Candy Cartwright) (SHINE 47)
- Defeated Chardonnay & Isla Dawn (SHINE 48)
- Defeated Ruthless Ambition (Maria Manic & Penelope Ford) (SHINE 50)
- Las Sicarias vs. Ruthless Ambition ended in a 30-Minute Time Limit Draw (SHINE 51)
Twisted Sisterz (July 20, 2018-January 19, 2019)[]
- Defeated Las Sicarias (Ivelisse & Mercedes Martinez), Team SPAM (Aerial Monroe & Aja Perera), and The Cutie Pie Club (Dementia D'Rose & Kiera Hogan) to become the new champions (SHINE 52)
- Four-Way Elimination Match
- Defeated The Cutie Pie Club (Dementia D'Rose & Kiera Hogan) (SHINE 53)
- Defeated Las Siscarias (SHINE 54)
Rainbow Bright (January 19, 2019-Current)[]
- Defeated Twisted Sisterz (Thunder Rosa & Holidead) to become the new champions (SHINE 56)
- Defeated by Twisted Sisterz by Countout; Rainbow Bright is still the champions.
- Defeated Twister Sisterz (SHINE 58)
- Lumberjill Match