Rain (12/07/13-01/24/14)
- Defeated Mia Yim in tournament finals to become inaugural champion (SHINE 11)
- Defeated Jessicka Havok (SHINE 12)
- Defeated Angelina Love (SHINE 13)
- Defeated Hiroyo Matsumoto (SHINE 14)
- Defeated Amazing Kong by Count Out (SHINE 15)
Ivelisse (01/24/14-11/16/14)
- Defeated Rain to become new champion (SHINE 16)
- Defeated Mercedes Martinez (SHINE 17)
- Defeated Leva (FIP Everything Burns 2014)
- Defeated Jazz (WWN A Wrestling Odyssey)
- Defeated Mercedes Martinez (DGUSA Mercury Rising 2014)
- Defeated Saraya Knight (SHINE 18)
- Versus Mia Yim, ended in No Contest (FIP Accelerate 2014)
- Versus Serena Deeb, ended in Draw (SHINE 20)
- Defeated Shanna (FIP Declaration of Independence 2014)
- Defeated La Rosa Negra (FIP Heatstroke 2014)
- Defeated Neveah (SHINE 21)
- Defeated Madison Eagles via Referee Decision (SHINE 22)
- Defeated Su Yung (WWNLive In China Night 1)
- Defeated Allysin Kay (WWNLive In China Night 2)
Mia Yim (11/16/14-04/03/15)
- Defeated Ivelisse to become new champion (WWNLive In China Night 4)
- Lost to Neveah via DQ (SHINE 23)
- Defeated Santana Garrett (SHINE 24)
- Defeated Neveah (SHINE 25)
- 2/3 falls match
Santana Garrett (04/03/15-12/11/15)
- Defeated Mia Yim to become new champion (SHINE 26)
- Santana was also NWA World Women's Champion at the time and her title was on the line as well during the match
- Defeated La Rosa Negra (ACW Retribution)
- Santana's NWA World Women's Championship was also on the line
- Defeated Andrea (EVOLVE 42)
- Defeated Crazy Mary Dobson (BELIEVE 99)
- Santana's NWA World Women's Championship was also on the line
- Defeated Mia Yim (SHINE 27)
- Defeated Ivelisse via referee stoppage (SHINE 28)
- Defeated Allysin Kay (SHINE 29)
- Defeated Evie (SHINE 30)
- Defeated Saraya Knight (BELIEVE 109)
- Santana's NWA World Women's Championship was also on the line
Taylor Made (12/11/15-06/17/16)
- Defeated Santana Garrett to become new champion (SHINE 31)
- Defeated Santana Garrett (SHINE 32)
- Defeated Kimber Lee (SHINE 33)
- Defeated Nicole Matthews (WWNLive SuperShow- Mercury Rising 2016)
- Ivelisse was supposed to challenge for the title at the event, but was not able to
- Defeated Jessicka Havok via DQ (SHINE 34)
Ivelisse, 2nd reign (06/17/16 - 01/13/17)
- Defeated Taylor Made, Allysin Kay, and Madison Eagles in a fatal four way match to become new champion (SHINE 35)
- This was originally a triple threat match, but Ivelisse got in by cashing in a Money in the Bank contract that she won earlier in the night
- The match was also contested for the TNA Knockouts Championship (Held by Allysin Kay) and the SHIMMER Championship (Held by Madison Eagles), where the stipulation was whoever was pinned/submitted would lose their championship
- Defeated Su Yung (SHINE 36)
- Defeated LuFisto (SHINE 37)
- Defeated Vanessa Kraven (SHINE 38)
- Defeated C4 (Kennadi Brink, Amber O'Neal, Andrea, and LuFisto) (SHINE 39)
- This was an 8 person tag team match where Ivelisse teamed up with Amanda Carolina Rodriguez, Mercedes Martinez, and Thea Trinidad against C4.
- The stipulation was whoever was pinned had to leave SHINE, which was Andrea. Plus, if Ivelisse was pinned, she would also have lost her title
LuFisto (01/13/17-Current)
- Defeated Allysin Kay and Mercedes Martinez in a triple threat match to win the vacant championship (SHINE 40)
- Ivelisse was not medically cleared to compete at the event, so therefore, she was stripped of the title, resulting in the triple threat matchup
- Defeated Ivelisse (SHINE 41)
- Defeated Toni Storm (WWNLive SuperShow- Mercury Rising 2017: EVOLVE vs Progress)
- Su Yung was supposed to challenge for the title at the event, but was not able to
- Defeated Leva Bates (SHINE 42)
- Defeated Allysin Kay via DQ (SHINE 44)