On the May 26, 2008 edition of RAW, Ted DiBiase made an appearance and introduced his son Ted DiBiase Jr., who confronted then-World Tag Team Champions Cody Rhodes and Hardcore Holly. He expressed his intention on winning the titles and challenged them to a future match. At Night of Champions 2008 Rhodes turned on Holly and revealed himself to be DiBiase's partner. The team would win the tag team titles once more in August, defeating John Cena and Batista in a rematch a week after losing them to the team.
Around this time, Randy Orton would begin confronting and criticizing the team, questioning their passion. At Unforgiven 2008, Manu made his debut with the team, helping them attack World Heavyweight Champion CM Punk in order to prove a point to Orton. They lost the tag titles to Punk and Kofi Kingston on the October 27 edition of Raw, and a week later DiBiase would be attacked by Orton after the trio interfered in his match with Punk. Rhodes and Manu would then go on to form The Legacy with Orton. On January 12 edition of Raw, DiBiase returned, and joined The Legacy. That same night, the original Priceless(Rhodes and DiBiase), turned on their former teammate, Manu.
Championships and accomplishments
- World Tag Team Champions (2 times)