PREMIER Mr. Athletic Vs. Old School took place in Gilroy, California. The event took place on December 15, 2013.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- Singles Match: Buddy Royal defeated John Redito (2:59)
- Singles Match: Marcus Lewis defeated Dylan Drake (5:01)
- Singles Match: Dave Dutra defeated Nick Ruiz (7:30)
- Singles Match: The Almighty Sheik defeated Julio Pedroza (6:08)
- Singles Match: Cole Pistol defeated Nicole Savoy (3:25)
- Singles Match: JR Kratos defeated Brian Tannen (8:05)
- PREMIER Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership Match: Sledge defeated Timothy Thatcher (8:52)
- PREMIER Heavyweight Title Match: Jeff Cobb (c) vs. Oliver John - Time Limit Draw (30:00)
|PREMIER Wrestling events|
|Debut Show • 6/9 • 9/29 • Mr. Athletic Vs. Old School|