The roster of wrestlers for New Age Wrestling tends to vary as the promotion does not operate through contracts. It basically books whoever it wants either on a spasmodic or regular basis. The following is a list of wrestlers who have worked for the company but not in 2015, and have held any of the titles or are otherwise notable for other reasons.
- Joel Bateman
- Billy Blaze
- Bulk Bogan
- Candyman
- Carnage
- Chip
- Stephan Cool
- Sheik El Zacqwi
- The Enforcer
- Frankie the Frog
- Insaino
- James Jackson
- George Julio
- Barry Lawrence
- Lowzen
- Mike Manson
- Charlie Marciano
- Nikita Naridian
- Pitbull
- Pyro
- Rack Dogg
- Ashton Reid
- Rhino
- Sara Jay
- Scorpion
- Shemal
- Slikk Steev
- Sammy Souvlaki
- Tank
- Taxman
- Thunder Kid
- Steve Valek
- Voodoo