NYWC Master Of The Mat took place in Deer Park, New York. The event took place on May 21, 2016.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- The A-Listers (Alvin Alvarez, Cono, J-Redd, & Ultimo Maya) def. others in a NYWC Fusion Championship #1 Contendership Battle Royal
- Flawless & Lawless (Blake Morris & Rex Lawless) (c) def. The Hounds Of Hatred (Bam Sullivan & Boo Sullivan) and The Beaver Boys (Alex Reynolds & John Silver) in a three-way tag match for the NYWC Tag Team Championship
- Joel Maximo def. Joe Ettell
- Brad Benson, CJ Bambino, Juba & Randy Summers def. Apollyon, General Romero, King Mega & Otto Von Knox in an Eight Man Tag Match
- The Big O (c) def. The A-Listers (Alvin Alvarez, Cono, J-Redd & Ultimo Maya) in a Five on one handicap match for the NYWC Fusion Championship
- Dan Barry def. Mouse
- Tyler Murphy def. Aiden Baal, Anthony Gangone, DJ Hyde, Jesse Vane & Maxwell Jacob Feinstein in a six-way match
- JT Kasin def. Stockade (c) by DQ for the NYWC Heavyweight Championship
- Willow Nightingale (c) def. Sammy Pickles for the NYWC Starlet Championship
- Anthony Nese def. Big Damo, Bull James & Tracey Williams in a fourway match