NYWC Hotter Than Hell 2016 took place in Deer Park, New York. The event took place on August 25, 2016.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- Alvin Alvarez vs. J-Redd ended in a No Contest
- Tyler Murphy (c) defeated Anthony Gangone to retain the NYWC Fusion Championship
- Brad Benson & CJ Benson defeated The New Heavenly Bodies (Desirable Dustin & Gigolo Justin)
- DJ Hyde defeated Gianni Valletta
- The Hounds of Hatred (Boo Sullivan & Bamm Sullivan) (c) defeated Flawless & Lawless (Blake Morris & Rex Lawless) to retain the NYWC Tag Team Championship
- Bull James defeated Mike Verna
- Mike Orlando defeated ???
- Deonna Purrazzo & Sammy Pickles defeated Brooke Danielle & Layne Rosario
- Devil Doll defeated Deonna Purrazzo (c) to win the NYWC Starlet Championship
- Talon defeated Ryan Donovan
- Jesse Vane & Joe Gacy defeated The Hounds of Hatred (King Mega & Apollyon)
- Papadon defeated Maxwell Jacob Feinstein
- JT Kasin & Randy Summers defeated The Hounds of Hatred (Mouse & Stockade)