NYWC Aftermath 2017 took place in Deer Park, New York. The event took place on March 25, 2017.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- General Romero vs JT Kasin resulted in a No Contest
- DJ Hyde defeated Joe Ettell
- King Mega defeated Papadon
- The Benson Brothers (Brad Benson & CJ Benson) defeated Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts & Randy Summers)
- Big O (c) vs Mike Verna for the NYWC Fusion Championship resulted in a No Contest
- Big O & Mike Verna defeated Mr. A & Tyler Murphy
- Angelo Andrews defeated Aiden Baal, Alvin Alvarez, Rex Lawless, Spyder & Talon in a Suicidal Six Way match
- Willow Nightingale (c) defeated Rick Cataldo to retain the NYWC Starlet Championship
- Anthony LaCerra & Jesse Vane (c) defeated Private Party (Isiah Kassidy & Marq Quen) to retain the NYWC Tag Team Championship
- Bull James (c) defeated Homicide to retain the NYWC Heavyweight Championship