NJPW Presents CMLL Fantastica Mania 2011 - Day 2 took place in Tokyo. The event took place on January 23, 2011. It was broadcast on Samurai! TV.
- Numbers in parentheses indicate the length of the match.
- (c) refers to the champion(s) heading into the match.
- La Sombra defeats Takahashi (5:18)
- Dorada defeats Naito (5:31)
- Naito defeats Dorada (10:06)
- OKAMURA defeats La Sombra (10:20)
- Mascara defeats OKUMURA (14:34)
- Mistico defeats Averno [2:1] in a Best Two Out Of Three Falls Match (16:50)
- Averno defeats Mistico (3:06)
- Mistico defeats Averno (4:59)
- Mistico defeats Averno (16:50)