He began his professional wrestling career in 2007 training under Kent Wilson at Adrenaline Unleashed, as one of the company's very first students. Lindley worked for several Nevada based companies in the early days of his career including Vegas Championship Wrestling, and Future Stars of Wrestling.
January 2011, Justyn moved to upstate New York, where he then began working for 3DW in Endicott New York under the ring name Jay Jameson.
In mid 2012 Justyn returned home to Las Vegas, and reunited with local promotions as Justyn Michael.
August 2015 Justyn debuted in Extreme Ring Action with a victory over former UCW-Zero Champion Big Vig. Justyn would stack up several more singles wins in the company. December 2015 at the ERA Holiday Havoc event, Justyn would defeat Sinn Bodhi to become Number One Contender for the Heavyweight Championship. March 30th 2016 at ERA's very first "Wrestlution" Super Card. Justyn would defeat Matt Cross to become the second ever ERA Heavyweight Champion.
Septermber of 2016, it was announced Rebelious Nature Lifestyle Brand would add Justyn Michael as their very first sponsored athlete.
3DW (New York)
April 2011 Justyn moved to New York and signed a wrestler's contract to 3DW. He debuted at 3DW's Born to Bleed 4-22-11 in Sidney, New York in a tag team match, teaming with Joey Image to take on The Gods of Destruction. Justyn tagged in Joey hoping for a hot tag from his fresh partner. Joey instead of attacking the other team turned around and tagged Justyn back into the match. This caused instant heat on Joey from the crowd. The God's of Destruction then hit several double team moves on Justyn for the win.He worked 3DW's "Shocker" event in June 2011 teaming with Chris Knievil and Johnny Kadilac to take on The Hilbilies and Super Bad. This would be his last match for the company.
Extreme Ring Action
On August 2, 2015 Extreme Ring Action (ERA) held it's first evet. Justyn made his in ring return at the event ERA "Extreme Arrival" defeating Big Vig in a one on one contest. August 17 of 2015, ERA announced Justyn as a trainer at the ERA Wrestling Academy. November 2015 ERA held a charity event for veterans at the American Legion Post 8 I'm Las Vegas, where Justyn alongside Austin Hale would defeat Michael Hyde and Paranormal (Better known as The Afflicted)
On December 27, 2015, Justyn allied himself with Michael Hyde, and Paranormal, joining The Afflicted after achieving a pin fall victory over Sinn Bodhi. The win over Sinn Bodhi, would make Justyn number one contender for the ERA Heavyweight Championship.
On March 28, 2016, Matt Cross defeated Justyn to retain the title, until general manager David Steele would restart the match, taking a heel turn, allowing Justyn to attack Cross from behind, and pick up a pin fall victory over Cross to become the new ERA Heavyweight Champion. Later that week, Justyn defended the title against Sinn Bodhi at the 2016 "Extreme Thing" sports and music festival. The company later went on hiatus due to personal issues between the founders. Extreme Ring Action would return in Janurary of 2017 with H&R Block as an official sponsor. At the H&R Block "Block Party" event on January 21, 2017 ERA began filming their own local television series titled "Fury TV" where Justyn defended the ERA title against Looney Bin Dudley. The match ended in a no contest, after an interference from Michael Hyde. This controversy would lead officials to vacant the ERA Heavyweight Championship. Justyn Michael would publicly quit ERA because of the decision.
At the 2016 Extreme Thing event, Justyn debuted in his first spot with NoizeTV. Alongside Michael Hyde, Justyn defeated NoizeTV hosts Shay and Stiffy, in what was a terribly hilarious match. This spot debuted in NoizeTV's first televised episode, in their first segment. Justyn returned to NoizeTV for Episode 4. "Para-Wrestling Activities" where he starred in an entire episode, and defeated his friends at Tonapah's Clown Motel and graveyard after their bodies were taken over by spirits. Justyn appeared on "Haunted & Alone" a Paranormal podcast, where the NoizeTV producers announced him as the Undisputed Champion of the Underworld. A title that he now defends against any and all challengers. Living or otherwise.
Lindley spent several years working in and around the tattoo industry. He has decorated a large part of his body with tattoos, including full color portraits of his favorite wrestlers and inspirations covering most of his left leg. On the left side of his neck McConnell has the word "Je t'aime" (French for I love you) tattooed. This represents a close personal friend of his named Zoey, a talented artist that passed away in a traffic accident. Zoey loved the word, and incorporated it into many of her pieces. In April of 2017 Justyn would move to Attica, Michigan to settle down with his girlfriend.
- Finishing and signature moves
- Tombstone Piledriver
- Hammered (Headlock Driver)
- Deadline (Flying Clothesline to Seated Opponent)
- Sit-out Spinebuster
- "The Nightmare"
- "The Maniacal"
- Stables/Tag Teams
Championships and accomplishments
- Undisputed Underworld Championship (1 time) (Seasons 1-3)
- ERA Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
- AXPW Hardcore Championship (1 time)
- "I created a Monster" by The Animal In Me.
- "My Dick" by Mickey Avalon