Note MCM=Motor City Machine guns
- Victory Road 2004 Hector Garza won a "gauntlet" match
- Also in the match were: The Amazing Red, Mikey Batts, Jerrelle Clark, Jason Cross, D-Ray 3000, Sonjay, Dutt, Frankie Kazarian, Kazushi Miyamoto, Nosawa, L.A. Park, Psicosis, Puma, Chris Sabin, Michael Shane, Shark Boy, Alex Shelly, Sonny Siaki, Spanky, and Matt Sydal.
- Unbreakable 2005
- Genesis 2005 Christopher Daniels, Samoa Joe, Shelley, Roderick Strong def. Sonjay Dutt, Matt Bentley, Austin Aries, Chris Sabin in an elimination match
- Turning Point 2005 Austin Aries & Matt Bentley beat Roderick Strong & Alex Shelley
- Final Resolution 2006 Austin Aries, Roderick Strong, & Alex Shelley beat Matt Bentley, Sonjay Dutt, & Chris Sabin
- Against All Odds 2006 Jay Lethal def. Bently, Shelley & Petey Williams
- Destination X 2006 Shelley def. Lethal
- Lockdown 2006 Hirooki Goto, Black Tiger (Romero), & Minoru beat Alex Shelley, Sonjay Dutt, & Jay Lethal
- Sacrifice 2006 Petey Williams won a "gauntlet" match
- Also in the match were: Black Tiger (Romero), Johnny Devine, Sonjay Dutt, Tyson Dux, Incognito, Jay Lethal, Jushin Liger, Magno, Minoru, Puma, Chris Sabin, Alex Shelly, Shocker, Tatsutoshi Goto, & Eric Young.
- Slammiversary 2006 Senshi won a “six-way elimination” match
- Sonjay Dutt pinned Shark Boy
- Jay Lethal pinned Alex Shelley
- Petey Williams pinned Lethal
- Senshi pinned Williams
- Senshi pinned Dutt
- Victory Road 2006 Lethal & Sabin def. Nash & Shelley
- Hard Justice 2006 Sabin def. Shelley
- No Surrender 2006 Andy Douglas & Chase Stevens won a "tag team battle royal"
- Also in the match were: Shark Boy & Norman Smiley, Johnny Devine & Alex Shelley, David Young & Elix Skipper, Chris Harris & James Storm, Ron Killings & Lance Hoyt, Matt Bentley & Frankie Kazarian, and Kip & Brian James.
- Bound for Glory 2006
- Genesis 2006 Lance Hoyt & Ron "the truth" Killings def. Shelley & Austin Starr
- Turning Point 2006 Senshi beat Alex Shelley, Austin Starr, Sonjay Dutt, and Jay Lethal in a "five-way elimination" match.
- Dutt beat Shelley (7:52) via submission.
- Senshi pinned Lethal (8:50).
- Starr pinned Dutt (13:12).
- Senshi pinned Starr (14:38).
- Final Resolution 2007 Shelley def. Starr
- Lockdown 2007 X Division Champion Chris Sabin beat Shark Boy, Shelley, Jay Lethal, & Sonjay Dutt in an "steel cage elimination" match.
Shelley pinned Shark Boy Sabin pinned Dutt Lethal pinned Shelley Sabin escaped the cage
- Slammiversary 2007 Bob Backlund pinned Alex Shelley
- Victory Road 2007 MCM def. Backlund & Jerry Lynn
- Hard Justice 2007 Lethal & Dutt Def. Daniels & Senshii & MCM
- No Surrender 2007 AJ Styles & Travis Tomko won a "tag team gauntlet" match
- Also in the match were: BG & Kip James, Homicide & Hernandez, Team 3-D, Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley, Christopher Daniels & Elix Skipper, Sonjay Dutt & Petey Williams, Raven & Havok, Eric Young & Shark Boy, and Lance Hoyt & Jimmy Rave.
- Bound for Glory 2007 Eric Young won a "reverse battle royal"
- Also in the match were: Sonjay Dutt, Junior Fatu, Chris Harris, Lance Hoyt, BG James, Kip James, Frankie Kazarian, Jimmy Rave, Robert Roode, Chris Sabin, Shark Boy, Alex Shelley, James Storm, and Petey Williams
- Genesis 2007 Motor City Machine Guns def. Team 3D
- Turning Point 2007 Team 3-D & Johnny Devine beat Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin, & Jay Lethal in a tables match
- Final Resolution 2008 Team 3-D & Johnny Devine beat Chris Sabin, Alex Shelley, & Jay Lethal
- Against All Odds 2008 MCM & Jay Lethal def. Team 3D, Johnny Devine
- as a result Lethal won the X division title that Devine and Team 3-D stole from the X division
- Lockdown 2008 Kaz & Super Eric (Eric Young) beat Lance Hoyt & Jimmy Rave, Homicide & Hernandez, Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley, Scott Steiner & Petey Williams, and Rellik & Black Reign in a "handcuff steel cage" match.
- Sacrifice 2008 Kaz won a "terror dome" match
- Also in the match were: Consequences Creed, Curry Man, Johnny Devine, Sonjay Dutt, Jay Lethal, Jimmy Rave, Chris Sabin, Shark Boy, and Alex Shelley.
- Victory Road 2008 Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin, & Curry Man beat Tyson Dux, Doug Williams, & Alex Koslov and Masato Yoshino, Milano Collection AT, & Puma and Ultimo Guerrero, Rey Bucanero, & Averno (24:16) in an "elimination" match. Shelley was the sole survivor.
- Bucanero pinned Dux
- Averno pinned Puma
- Sabin pinned AT
- Yoshino pinned Averno
- Guerrero pinned Curry Man
- Bucanero pinned Williams
- Koslov pinned Guerrero
- Sabin pinned Bucanero
- Koslov pinned Sabin
- Yoshino beat Koslov
- Shelley pinned Yoshino
- Bound for Glory 2008 Jay Lethal won a "steel asylum" match
- Also in the match were: Curry Man, Johnny Devine, Sonjay Dutt, Jimmy Rave, Chris Sabin, Shark Boy, Alex Shelley, Super Eric, and Petey Williams.
- Turning Point 2008 TNA World Tag Team Championship Beer Money Inc. def. MCM
- Final Resolution 2008 Jay Lethal, Curry Man, Hernandez, and Homicide won the "feast or fired battle royal"
- Also in the match were: Consequences Creed, Sonjay Dutt, BG James, Kip James, Jimmy Rave, Lance Rock, Chris Sabin, Shark Boy, and Alex Shelley
- Genesis 2009 Shelley def. MCM tag partner Chris Sabin to win the vacant TNA X Division Championship
- the title was vacated due to Shane Sewell attacking Sheik Abdul Bashir and effecting the title change when Eric Young defeated Bashir for the title
- Against All Odds 2009 Shelley def. Eric Young to defend the title
- Destination X 2009 Suicide (Christopher Daniels) def. Shelley, Sabin, Jay Lethal, Consesquenses Creed
- Lockdown 2009 IWGP champions Motor City Machine Guns def. Latin American Exchange & No Limit
- Sacrifice 2009 Lethal, Creed, Young def. MCM & Bashir
- Slammiversary 2009 Suicide (Christopher Daniels) def. Shelley, Sabin, Jay Lethal, Consesquenses Creed in a King of the Mountain match